Many people prescribed antibiotics in the U.S. don’t need them, and a study suggests this is particularly true for Black and Hispanic individuals.
By Lisa Rapapor – April 28, 2022
Two-thirds of antibiotics prescribed to Black people are unnecessary, as are more than half of such prescriptions for Hispanic individuals, according to preliminary results from a recent study.
Three in four antibiotics prescriptions for patients 65 and older aren’t needed, a recent study found. Two-thirds of antibiotics prescribed to Black people are unnecessary, as are more than half of such prescriptions for Hispanic individuals, according to preliminary results from a study presented at the European Congress of Clinical Microbiology and Infectious Diseases in Lisbon.
“Our results suggest that Black and Hispanic/Latinx patients may not be properly treated and are receiving antibiotic prescriptions even when not indicated,” said an author of the study, Eric Young, of University of Texas Health Science Center in San Antonio, in a statement.
Particularly for elderly patients, the stakes of these unnecessary prescriptions are high, Young said. “In older adults, inappropriate prescribing in primary care is associated with a wide range of adverse outcomes, including emergency hospital attendances and admissions, adverse drug events, and poorer quality of life,” Young said.
For the study, researchers examined data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) on prescriptions written during outpatient visits for more than 5.7 billion adults and 1.3 billion children between 2009 and 2016. Overall, 11 percent of these patient visits resulted in antibiotics prescriptions, the analysis found.
Antibiotics should be prescribed only for bacterial infections, which can include strep throat, bloodstream infections, bacterial pneumonia, urinary tract infections, and some types of ear infections. Antibiotics are ineffective against viral infections, such as the flu, and shouldn’t be used for viral illnesses.
Most often, when antibiotics were used inappropriately in the study, doctors offered these medicines to treat viral infections, bronchitis, or skin conditions unrelated to bacterial infections, the analysis found.
One limitation of the study is that it looked only at outpatient visits, not at antibiotic use inside hospitals. Another drawback is that researchers lacked some data that might have influenced prescribing decisions, such as patient allergies or certain diagnoses that might warrant use of antibiotics. The results have not been published in a peer-reviewed medical journal, a process that typically involves an independent verification of the findings.
While the study wasn’t designed to determine why so many patients got antibiotics they didn’t need, it’s possible that clinicians made decisions based at least in part on whether they thought people might be able to return to the doctor if their condition took a turn for the worse, Young said.
“We know that physicians typically send patients home with antibiotics if they suspect their symptoms may lead to an infection,” Young said. “This practice becomes more common when patients are unlikely to return for a follow-up visit or have no established care within a clinic or hospital system, which more frequently happens in minority populations.”